Abhishek Srivastava of Times of India gave it a rating of 3.5 out of 5 saying that, Amber Girls School’ brings a breath of fresh air, yet it's not immune to clichés that could have been avoided. Set in Chandigarh in 2008, the series packs in Bollywood songs and cultural references from that time, effectively enhancing its appeal. Despite its reliance on familiar tropes, it offers a nostalgic journey for female viewers, reminiscent of their school days, though with a hint of scepticism. Sonal Pandya from Times Now gave it a rating 3 out of 5 saying that Amber Girls School works in large part due to Bairagey's appealing performance. At times, the young actress reminds one quite a bit of a young Alia Bhatt, especially in her appearance. The rest of the cast also create the strict atmosphere of rigidity and rules, with the young students wanting to break free of this uniformity.
